I must admit – even knowing that Tony Bourdain contributed to this book, I didn’t start reading it expecting too much. In fact – after reading the first few stories I wasn’t getting into it and wasn’t sure if I wanted to continue reading it.
The book features a great lineup of writers. Ferran Adria, Mario Batali, Heston Blumenthal, Bourdain, Tamasin Day-Lewis, Gabrielle Hamilton, Fergus Henderson, Eric Ripart, Marcus Samuelsson and Norman Van Aken are just a small sampling of the talented chef contributors. The problem is that even though they are all (presumably) great chefs, not all of them are stellar writers.
I’ve been in the food business most of my life – and I have great stories I can tell about kitchen catastrophes – so I would assume these kitchen luminaries would them too. And many of them do. But several of the writers are stretching in their attempts – it’s as though, miraculously, nothing really bad has ever happened in their kitchens, but they had to come up with something for the book. And some of the attempts fall flat.
On the other hand, some of the stories are great. At first, I thought that Tony Bourdain was an anomaly – he’s a storyteller with a gift. He tells the tale of a New Year’s Eve shift that anybody in the hospitality business would fear. And of course he tells it in his usual brash, honest way.
Not everybody has the writing talent that AB does. But as I continued to read, I found several gems within the red and orange cover. Gabrielle Hamilton retells a touching story of a hopeful, blind line-cook. As AB himself points out in his last book – this woman has talent. Though he may say that because she comes across as a female version of him. I hope to read more from her in the future.
Michelle Bernstein’s story is one of turning a mistake into success. Michael Lomonaco recounts his near heart-break – a most exciting evening for him that came close to not happening. Sara Moulton – TV host, Gourmet magazine chef – but first and foremost, little sister – tells about how one mistake can never be forgotten when a sibling is there as a witness.
These were some of the stories that stuck with me as I read through the book – and I’m glad I didn’t put it down at the beginning. By the end, I felt like the good stuff far out-weighed the bad (bad is too harsh a word – let’s just call it the not-so-great).
Once I got through the first few stories, the book turned into an easy-to-read, enjoyable adventure. Do I think everybody will enjoy it? Parts of it yes. To enjoy all of it, I think it helps to have put in some time in the food biz. I say give it a shot – if one story doesn’t float your boat, just move on to the next.
What people are saying…